Songhai Wire › Editorial
Editorial · Songhai Wire, Series 01

Ghana has already lived through what the rest of the world is being warned about.

Record debt meeting an inflationary supply shock is a hypothetical in most markets. In Ghana it is a completed event, with survivors and casualties, inside living memory. We hold the wholesale price record from that window, and this is what we intend to do with it.

The lineage

In 1843 a Scottish hat-maker named James Wilson founded a newspaper to fight a grain-price injustice: the Corn Laws, which kept bread dear for the many to protect the margins of the few. He promised readers that sound principles would be, in his words, “most rigidly applied to all the important questions of the day.” That paper became The Economist.

In 1909 an American reporter named Warren C. Platt started a petroleum trade journal on a simpler conviction: that the men who bought and sold oil deserved to know its real price, and that the companies who preferred the price obscure should not be the ones deciding it. His price sheets became the benchmarks the world's oil still trades against.

Both began as publications and became infrastructure. Neither started with the number it ended up owning. That sequence — argument first, benchmark second — is the one we are following, and the reason this editorial leads with a case rather than a price.

The argument

For four years economists have warned of a particular kind of crisis: debt at record levels meeting an inflationary supply shock, leaving central banks trapped between raising rates into a debt crisis and letting inflation run. The warning is that they choose the second — that they accept higher inflation for years and let the real value of nominal claims be ground away. Savings, bonds, pensions and fixed contracts are diminished. Real productive assets are not.

Ghana has already been through it. Inflation passed fifty per cent at the end of 2022. The cedi lost roughly half its value against the dollar across that year. The country defaulted on its external debt, and the Domestic Debt Exchange Programme took a haircut out of domestic bondholders — pension funds, banks and ordinary savers whose only error was holding a nominal claim.

The question that follows is the one nobody has answered with evidence: when the paper claims were destroyed, what happened to the real ones?

Figure 1 The crisis window Cedis per US dollar, daily, and white maize at two markets, monthly.
Maize prices, lower panel

    Select the chart and use the left and right arrow keys to move one business day at a time.

    The chart needs JavaScript. The monthly numbers are in the table below.

    Exchange rate: Bank of Ghana, historical interbank FX rates, US dollar mid rate, business days. Maize: Birkdal Partners wholesale archive (v2), monthly medians. US$ per tonne uses that month's median exchange rate.

    Show the numbers
    Monthly, January 2022 to June 2024
    MonthGH¢ per US$Techiman GH¢/kgWenchi GH¢/kgTechiman US$/tWenchi US$/t
    Jan 20226.01––––
    Feb 20226.30––––
    Mar 20227.04––––
    Apr 20227.11––––
    May 20227.13––––
    Jun 20227.20––––
    Jul 20227.38––––
    Aug 20228.09––––
    Sep 20228.28––––
    Oct 202210.87––––
    Nov 202213.09––––
    Dec 20228.58––––
    Jan 202310.354.805.01 thin464484 thin
    Feb 202310.805.245.25 thin485486 thin
    Mar 202311.015.475.52 thin497501 thin
    Apr 202310.94no recordno recordno recordno record
    May 202310.95no recordno recordno recordno record
    Jun 202310.98no recordno recordno recordno record
    Jul 202311.005.37 thin6.12 thin488 thin556 thin
    Aug 202311.015.38 thin4.38 thin489 thin398 thin
    Sep 202311.07no recordno recordno recordno record
    Oct 202311.33no recordno recordno recordno record
    Nov 202311.553.70 thin4.64 thin320 thin402 thin
    Dec 202311.643.573.94 thin307338 thin
    Jan 202411.91––––
    Feb 202412.18no recordno recordno recordno record
    Mar 202412.603.704.00 thin294317 thin
    Apr 202413.00–4.52 thin–348 thin
    May 202413.79––––
    Jun 202414.30––––

    The record

    It can be answered here because the record exists. The wholesale price record of Ghana's grain, oilseed, root and input markets, from January 2023 through April 2024 — the window of the default, the debt exchange and the disinflation that followed. Maize, soya, sorghum, cowpea, groundnut, millet and rice, traded in the standard bags of Techiman, Kumasi and Bolgatanga.

    The archive is kept to the Birkdal Methodology, and the findings drawn from it are published in the Library.

    Basis

    Analysis in this editorial draws on the historical archive. Assessment series are governed by the Methodology.

    The second gap

    Every week thousands of tonnes of grain change hands in Techiman, Kumasi, Bolgatanga and a dozen markets between. There is no number the farmer in Wenchi, the aggregator in Kintampo, the feed miller in Kumasi, the banker in Accra and the investor in London can all look at and agree is the price. The wholesaler knows what she paid this morning. The farmer three hours north does not. The investor deciding whether Ghanaian agriculture deserves capital knows least, and prices risk accordingly. The cost of that is borne right along the chain, and most heavily at the end of it with the least capacity to carry it.

    There is a second layer, less discussed and more expensive. Every trader in Techiman quotes in cedis; every investor weighing Ghanaian agriculture thinks in dollars. Between those two facts sits the most under-reported number in Ghanaian agribusiness — the real, currency-adjusted price of grain. A move in the cedi changes the domestic price of grain and the dollar price of grain in opposite directions, and a series reported in one denomination will not show it.

    What Songhai Wire publishes

    1. Analysis built on the record. The 2023–24 archive, cleaned, documented, and always presented as what it is. We do not dress two-year-old data as this morning's price.
    2. Every price in three denominations — cedis per kilogram, dollars per tonne, and deflated to real terms. The three tell three different stories and usually only one is told.
    3. Currency and import parity. The arithmetic of whether imported grain lands cheaper than local grain, decomposed into world price, freight, insurance, duty, exchange rate and inland transport. This decides whether import substitution is a slogan or a business.
    4. A house view, labelled as such — with its horizon, the mechanism it depends on, and a plain statement of what would prove it wrong.
    5. A scorecard. We revisit our own calls in public and mark them. Where we are wrong we record it at the length at which we made the original claim.
    6. A published methodology and a disclosed interest. Both below, and both in full on their own pages.

    The benchmark

    The objective is the price benchmark for Ghanaian agriculture: weekly assessed prices at named markets, each with a permanent symbol, its observation count and its range, so that a number can be checked, contracted against and, in time, traded on. Regional coverage, forward indications and programmatic access follow.

    Assessed prices require collection from named markets on defined days. Assessment series are in build under the Methodology, and each is published with the observation count behind every number.

    Independence, disclosed

    Songhai Wire is published by Birkdal Partners Ltd, which originates farmland and forward supply contracts in Ghana and West Africa. Birkdal assembles and de-risks farmland and leases developed blocks to commercial farming operators. It therefore holds a direct commercial interest in West African agriculture succeeding.

    That is stated here, at the front, in the first thing published under this masthead, because a reader cannot weigh the numbers without it. Some price reporting agencies are owned by houses with no stake in what they report. That is not our position and we will not imply that it is.

    What is offered instead of a claim to disinterest is a set of controls a reader can check: assessments produced mechanically under a published methodology; every number reconstructible from its inputs; observation counts printed whether or not they flatter us; exclusions recorded with reasons; commentary separated from data and never an input to it. Birkdal's own forward contracts are reference-priced against the Ghana Commodity Exchange, never against a Songhai Wire assessment.

    And an undertaking, published in the methodology so it can be held against us: before any third party marks collateral or settles a contract against a Songhai Wire number, we will put independent assurance over the process that produces it.

    Scale

    Benchmarks start narrow: one argument, properly evidenced; one basis market; eight assessed prices.

    Wilson's contest between intelligence and ignorance has not finished; it has moved. It is consequential in the markets that feed West Africa, and it is decided by numbers rather than by assertion. That is the work.

    — The Editor
    Accra & Techiman

    Songhai Wire

    The research notes.

    Market segmentation in white maize, import parity at Tema, and the cost of carrying grain.

    Songhai Wire →